Field note N° 03 · Provenance

What “verified” actually means here

“Verified” is a strong word, and it should have a narrow meaning. Here it is: a value in the draft model can be traced to the evidence it came from, and a person reviewed it.

Traceability first. Every accepted value links to its source — the field photo or the drawing it was read from. Open the value and you see the evidence, not a claim about the evidence. If a number cannot be pointed back to something visible, it does not enter the model as fact.

Review second. Values arrive in one of three states. Read cleanly from a legible source. Read with low confidence — the source is damaged, the photograph is poor, the character could be one of two things — and flagged for a human decision. Or not readable at all, in which case the field stays empty and flagged rather than estimated. A reviewer accepts, corrects, or rejects each flagged item, and that decision is recorded. Verified is the state of a value after those two steps: sourced, and seen by a person who took responsibility for it.

What verified does not mean is just as important. It does not mean calculated. ElecProof does not compute fault current, incident energy, or PPE categories, and it does not check your system against the code. It does not mean approved, sealed, or signed. The study is still run in your own engineering software, by your engineers, and your PE reviews and signs it. ElecProof's work ends where professional judgment begins, and the boundary is deliberate.

Why the narrow definition is worth the trouble: accountability over time. Studies get revisited — at the five-year review, after a system change, after an incident. When a value is questioned two years later, “the software produced it” is not an answer. A link to the photograph it was read from, and the name of the reviewer who accepted it, is an answer. That is the whole claim: every value has a source, every uncertainty is visible, and every decision has a person behind it.

More field notes

ElecProof turns field photos and old drawings into a verified draft model — every value linked to its source. See pilot pricing.